In this week’s episode of The Late Sub, host Claire Watkins digs into what happened to Gotham FC’s 2024 superteam — and whether the NWSL is built for such blockbuster rosters.
With the NJ/NY club kicking off with the same record over the first seven matches in 2025 as the 2024 roster achieved, Watkins uses Gotham to explore “a case study of how a super team does not work in the NWSL.”
First, Watkins explains exactly what is meant by a superteam, defining the concept as being rooted in procuring massive talent through free agency — a strategy Gotham employed by signing four former No. 1 NWSL Draft picks and current USWNT veterans Rose Lavelle, Emily Sonnett, Tierna Davidson, and Crystal Dunn to build their 2024 superteam.
“Gotham is a perfect example of why super teams do not translate to the NWSL,” says Watkins. “They were very good last year, they finished top four, they make it to the semifinals. They didn’t win anything.”
The reasons for the failure of a superteam in the NWSL, according to Watkins, include the pressures faced by players balancing the needs of their stacked club roster with their individual development needs to stay atop the international game.
“They need to be playing a certain amount of minutes. They need to be playing in…
